diff --git a/CHANGELOG.md b/CHANGELOG.md
index 992a9ba..fc596c0 100644
--- a/CHANGELOG.md
+++ b/CHANGELOG.md
@@ -23,6 +23,12 @@ adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0.html).
 - **Logging in to an account that is open on another computer asks first**, and **Move it here**
   has that computer log out of it, so the two sessions do not keep disconnecting each other.
 
+### Fixed
+
+- The Long and Short Position tools shade the trade from the bar where price reached the entry, as
+  TradingView does, instead of from the tool's left edge. A position whose entry price is never
+  reached shows no shading and no P&L.
+
 ## [1.0.0] - 2026-11-04
 
 ### Added
diff --git a/packages/meridian-charts/src/drawings/tools.test.ts b/packages/meridian-charts/src/drawings/tools.test.ts
index c7dbc57..ce86b4e 100644
--- a/packages/meridian-charts/src/drawings/tools.test.ts
+++ b/packages/meridian-charts/src/drawings/tools.test.ts
@@ -215,7 +215,8 @@ test('position labels show the quantity from account size, risk and lot size', (
   assert.ok(long.some((text) => text.includes('Risk/Reward Ratio: 2.00')));
   assert.ok(long.some((text) => text.startsWith('Target: 110.00') && text.includes('Amount: 20')));
   assert.ok(long.some((text) => text.startsWith('Stop: 95.00') && text.includes('Amount: 10')));
-  assert.ok(long.some((text) => /(Open|Closed) P&L: /.test(text)));
+  const filled = texts(build('long-position', [at(10, 105), at(30, 115), at(30, 100)], full));
+  assert.ok(filled.some((text) => /(Open|Closed) P&L: /.test(text)), 'P&L once price reaches the entry');
   // 2% of 5000 = 100 over 5 points with a lot size of 4: a quantity of 5.
   const custom = texts(build('long-position', [at(10, 100), at(30, 110), at(30, 95)], { ...full, accountSize: 5000, riskPercent: 2, lotSize: 4 }));
   assert.ok(custom.some((text) => text.includes('Qty: 5')), custom.join(' | '));
@@ -260,6 +261,22 @@ test('a position stops at the bar that hits its target or stop', () => {
   assert.equal(progressOf(build('long-position', [at(70, 105), at(90, 200), at(90, 50)])).length, 0, 'no bars after the entry, nothing to shade');
 });
 
+test('a position opens where price first reaches the entry, not at the entry anchor', () => {
+  const entry = 115;
+  const touch = bars.findIndex((bar, index) => index >= 10 && bar.low <= entry && bar.high >= entry);
+  assert.ok(touch > 10);
+  const shapes = build('long-position', [at(10, entry), at(80, 200), at(80, 50)]);
+  const [progress] = progressOf(shapes);
+  assert.ok(progress?.kind === 'rect');
+  assert.equal(progress.x, timeToX(bars[touch].time));
+  const trace = shapes.find((shape) => shape.kind === 'line' && shape.style.dash?.length);
+  assert.ok(trace?.kind === 'line');
+  assert.deepEqual(trace.a, { x: timeToX(bars[touch].time), y: priceToY(entry) });
+  const unfilled = build('long-position', [at(10, 300), at(80, 400), at(80, 50)], { showStats: true, isCompact: false });
+  assert.equal(progressOf(unfilled).length, 0, 'an entry price never reached opens nothing');
+  assert.ok(!texts(unfilled).some((text) => text.includes('P&L')));
+});
+
 test('line tools append price, bars and angle info on request', () => {
   const anchors = [at(5, 100), at(15, 110)];
   assert.deepEqual(texts(build('trend-line', anchors)), []);
diff --git a/packages/meridian-charts/src/drawings/tools.ts b/packages/meridian-charts/src/drawings/tools.ts
index 96ac689..3fcc741 100644
--- a/packages/meridian-charts/src/drawings/tools.ts
+++ b/packages/meridian-charts/src/drawings/tools.ts
@@ -559,17 +559,21 @@ const positionFields: ToolField[] = [
   checkbox('showStats', 'Always show stats'),
 ];
 
-// Follows price from the entry bar to the end of the position: the trade closes at the first bar
-// that touches the stop (checked first) or the target, else it is still open at the last close.
-function positionOutcome(env: ToolEnv, isLong: boolean, entry: DrawingPoint, end: number, target: number, stop: number): { exit: number; index: number; isClosed: boolean } | null {
+// As in TradingView, the trade opens at the first bar from the entry anchor that trades through the
+// entry price, and closes at the first bar from there that touches the stop (checked first) or the
+// target, else it is still open at the last close. A price that never reaches the entry opens nothing.
+function positionOutcome(env: ToolEnv, isLong: boolean, entry: DrawingPoint, end: number, target: number, stop: number): { exit: number; start: number; index: number; isClosed: boolean } | null {
   const range = barRange(env, entry.time, end);
   if (!range) return null;
-  for (let index = range[0]; index <= range[1]; index++) {
+  let start = range[0];
+  while (start <= range[1] && (env.bars[start].low > entry.price || env.bars[start].high < entry.price)) start++;
+  if (start > range[1]) return null;
+  for (let index = start; index <= range[1]; index++) {
     const bar = env.bars[index];
-    if (isLong ? bar.low <= stop : bar.high >= stop) return { exit: stop, index, isClosed: true };
-    if (isLong ? bar.high >= target : bar.low <= target) return { exit: target, index, isClosed: true };
+    if (isLong ? bar.low <= stop : bar.high >= stop) return { exit: stop, start, index, isClosed: true };
+    if (isLong ? bar.high >= target : bar.low <= target) return { exit: target, start, index, isClosed: true };
   }
-  return { exit: env.bars[range[1]].close, index: range[1], isClosed: false };
+  return { exit: env.bars[range[1]].close, start, index: range[1], isClosed: false };
 }
 
 function position(isLong: boolean): Build {
@@ -586,15 +590,16 @@ function position(isLong: boolean): Build {
     const opacity = o.num('areaOpacity') / 100;
     g.rect({ x: x0, y: entry.y }, { x: x1, y: target.y }, { width: 0, fill: profitColor, fillOpacity: opacity });
     g.rect({ x: x0, y: entry.y }, { x: x1, y: stop.y }, { width: 0, fill: stopColor, fillOpacity: opacity });
-    // As in TradingView, the trade so far is shaded darker: from the entry to the bar where it
-    // stands (the latest bar while open, the bar that hit the target or stop once closed), between
-    // the entry and that price, with a dashed line from the entry to it.
+    // As in TradingView, the trade so far is shaded darker: from the bar where price reached the
+    // entry to the bar where it stands (the latest bar while open, the bar that hit the target or
+    // stop once closed), between the entry and that price, with a dashed line along it.
     const outcome = targetPoint.time > entryPoint.time ? positionOutcome(env, isLong, entryPoint, targetPoint.time, targetPrice, stopPrice) : null;
     if (outcome) {
+      const opened = { x: env.timeToX(env.bars[outcome.start].time), y: entry.y };
       const exit = { x: env.timeToX(env.bars[outcome.index].time), y: env.priceToY(outcome.exit) };
       const isProfit = (outcome.exit - entryPrice) * (isLong ? 1 : -1) >= 0;
-      g.rect({ x: x0, y: entry.y }, exit, { width: 0, fill: isProfit ? profitColor : stopColor, fillOpacity: Math.min(1, opacity + 0.2) });
-      g.line({ x: x0, y: entry.y }, exit, { color: env.theme.muted, width: 1, dash: [4, 4] });
+      g.rect(opened, exit, { width: 0, fill: isProfit ? profitColor : stopColor, fillOpacity: Math.min(1, opacity + 0.2) });
+      g.line(opened, exit, { color: env.theme.muted, width: 1, dash: [4, 4] });
     }
     g.line({ x: x0, y: entry.y }, { x: x1, y: entry.y }, { color: env.theme.muted, width: 1 });
     const reward = Math.abs(targetPrice - entryPrice);