docs(research): land verified learning loop roadmap - #87
Conversation
|
ⓘ Qodo reviews are paused because your trial has ended. Ask your workspace admin to add credits to resume reviews. Manage billing |
|
Important
This repository does not receive automatic reviews because it has fewer than 10 stars. ⚙️ Run configurationConfiguration used: defaults Review profile: CHILL Plan: Team Run ID: Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. Comment |
|
@coderabbitai Please independently review the current landing surface against canonical Exact candidate head remains Please verify:
Report an explicit current-base exact-head |
|
Tip For best results, initiate chat on the files or code changes. 🧩 Analysis chain🏁 Script executed: #!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
repo="TheHalfMoon/Winds"
base="7302d1b91b1d5b6e2dbbb80893095d36183dc492"
head="78c7a88c6d809edaa4b8a3a339d367e9bc0cf140"
echo '== Local commit identities and ancestry =='
git show -s --format='commit=%H%nparents=%P%nsubject=%s' "$base" "$head"
printf 'merge_base='
git merge-base "$base" "$head"
printf 'base_is_ancestor_of_head='
git merge-base --is-ancestor "$base" "$head" && echo yes || echo no
printf 'head_is_ancestor_of_base='
git merge-base --is-ancestor "$head" "$base" && echo yes || echo no
echo '== Direct current-base changed files and status =='
git diff --name-status "$base" "$head"
echo '-- stats --'
git diff --stat "$base" "$head"
echo '-- patch --'
git diff --no-ext-diff --unified=80 "$base" "$head" -- \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-roadmap.md \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md
echo '== Canonical-base movement content =='
git diff --name-status 06e515471cf91a0f1d5b257d6e9820096d9a0197 "$base"
git diff --no-ext-diff --unified=40 06e515471cf91a0f1d5b257d6e9820096d9a0197 "$base" -- \
docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.md
echo '== Relevant document headings and authority-boundary terms =='
for f in \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-roadmap.md \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md \
docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.md
do
echo "-- $f --"
git show "$head:$f" 2>/dev/null || git show "$base:$f"
done | rg -n -i -C 2 \
'^(#|##|###)|non-author|authoriz|Spec 006|T079|T080|L0|L10|implement|runtime|migration|dependenc|fine.tun|reinforcement|self.modif|automatic landing|PR `#21`|NousResearch|hermes-agent|jennyzzt/dgm|license|reuse|SHA|commit'
echo '== GitHub pull request state, files, checks, and review comments =='
gh pr view 87 --repo "$repo" --json \
number,title,state,isDraft,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,baseRefName,baseRefOid,headRefName,headRefOid,commits,files,statusCheckRollup,reviews,comments \
--jq '{
number,title,state,isDraft,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,baseRefName,baseRefOid,headRefName,headRefOid,
commits:[.commits[]|{oid:.oid,messageHeadline:.messageHeadline}],
files:[.files[]|{path:.path,additions:.additions,deletions:.deletions}],
checks:[.statusCheckRollup[]|{name:(.name // .context),status:.status,conclusion:.conclusion,workflowName:.workflowName}],
reviews:[.reviews[]|{author:.author.login,state:.state,commit:.commit.oid,body:.body}],
comments:[.comments[]|{author:.author.login,body:.body}]
}'
echo '== Open review threads =='
gh api "repos/$repo/pulls/87/comments?per_page=100" --paginate \
--jq '.[] | {id, user:.user.login, path, line, side, body, in_reply_to_id}'Length of output: 106376 🏁 Script executed: #!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
repo="TheHalfMoon/Winds"
base="7302d1b91b1d5b6e2dbbb80893095d36183dc492"
head="78c7a88c6d809edaa4b8a3a339d367e9bc0cf140"
echo '== Synthetic merge result =='
merge_tree_output="$(git merge-tree --write-tree "$base" "$head")"
printf 'merge_tree=%s\n' "$merge_tree_output"
merge_tree="${merge_tree_output%%$'\n'*}"
git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r "$merge_tree"
echo '-- document identities in merge result --'
for f in \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-roadmap.md \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md \
docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.md
do
printf '%s ' "$f"
git rev-parse "$merge_tree:$f"
done
echo '-- merge result versus base --'
git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r "$base" "$merge_tree"
echo '== Locate active authority documents =='
fd -HI -t f -i 'constitution|spec.*006|tasks|plan' . \
-E .git -E target -E node_modules | sed -n '1,160p'
echo '== Authority-boundary references in repository documents =='
rg -n -i -C 2 \
'Spec 006|T079|T080|Constitution -> Spec -> Plan -> Tasks -> Implement|non-authoriz|learning|implementation' \
--glob '*.md' --glob '!docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-roadmap.md' \
--glob '!docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md' \
--glob '!docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.md' . | sed -n '1,280p'
echo '== Check runs associated with the exact head =='
gh api "repos/$repo/commits/$head/check-runs?per_page=100" \
-H 'Accept: application/vnd.github+json' \
--jq '.check_runs[] | {id,name,status,conclusion,started_at,completed_at,details_url,app:.app.slug}'
echo '== Commit statuses associated with the exact head =='
gh api "repos/$repo/commits/$head/status" \
--jq '{state, statuses:[.statuses[]|{context,state,created_at,target_url,description}]}'
echo '== Pull request required status-check configuration =='
gh api "repos/$repo/branches/main/protection/required_status_checks" 2>&1 || trueLength of output: 33163 🏁 Script executed: #!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
repo="TheHalfMoon/Winds"
head="78c7a88c6d809edaa4b8a3a339d367e9bc0cf140"
echo '== Pull request landing metadata =='
gh pr view 87 --repo "$repo" --json \
number,title,body,state,isDraft,baseRefOid,headRefOid,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,updatedAt \
--jq '{number,title,body,state,isDraft,baseRefOid,headRefOid,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,updatedAt}'
echo '== Exact-head checks, refreshed =='
gh api "repos/$repo/commits/$head/check-runs?per_page=100" \
-H 'Accept: application/vnd.github+json' \
--jq '.check_runs[] | {name,status,conclusion,started_at,completed_at,details_url,app:.app.slug}'
echo '== Pull request state, refreshed =='
gh pr view 87 --repo "$repo" --json mergeable,mergeStateStatus,headRefOid,baseRefOid,statusCheckRollup \
--jq '{
mergeable,mergeStateStatus,headRefOid,baseRefOid,
checks:[.statusCheckRollup[]|{name:(.name // .context),status,conclusion,workflowName}]
}'Length of output: 8824 🏁 Script executed: #!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
repo="TheHalfMoon/Winds"
head="78c7a88c6d809edaa4b8a3a339d367e9bc0cf140"
echo '== Final exact-head check state =='
gh api "repos/$repo/commits/$head/check-runs?per_page=100" \
-H 'Accept: application/vnd.github+json' \
--jq '.check_runs[] | {name,status,conclusion,started_at,completed_at,details_url,app:.app.slug}'
echo '== Final pull request state =='
gh pr view 87 --repo "$repo" --json \
state,isDraft,baseRefOid,headRefOid,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,statusCheckRollup,reviews \
--jq '{
state,isDraft,baseRefOid,headRefOid,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,
checks:[.statusCheckRollup[]|{name:(.name // .context),status,conclusion,workflowName}],
reviews:[.reviews[]|{author:.author.login,state:.state,commit:.commit.oid,body:.body}]
}'
echo '== Pull request review comments =='
gh api "repos/$repo/pulls/87/comments?per_page=100" --paginate \
--jq '.[] | {user:.user.login,path,line,side,body,in_reply_to_id}'Length of output: 3259
I verified these facts:
I cannot issue the requested unconditional current-base exact-head The current exact-head Ubuntu quality job passed. The current exact-head macOS quality job and Cubic review remain Issue the final landing You are interacting with an AI system. |
TheHalfMoon
left a comment
TheHalfMoon
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
LANDING_CURRENT_BASE_AUTHOR_REVIEW_PASS
Exact landing state:
CURRENT_BASE=7302d1b91b1d5b6e2dbbb80893095d36183dc492
EXACT_HEAD=78c7a88c6d809edaa4b8a3a339d367e9bc0cf140
CHANGED_PATHS=2
QUALITY_846=SUCCESS
MERGEABLE=YES
Author correctness / governance / provenance reconciliation against the current canonical base: PASS.
Facts checked:
- current
maindiffers from the previously reviewed base only by guarded research-only PR #85, which addsdocs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.mdand explicitly creates no Spec 006/T079/T080 implementation authority; - the Verified Learning candidate head has not moved;
- the PR diff remains exactly the roadmap plus primary-source register;
- the Hermes and DGM provenance repairs remain intact;
- no runtime code, dependency, migration, Constitution, Spec, Plan, Tasks, model call, or authority surface is changed;
- the two research roadmaps are additive and do not conflict semantically: both require post-Spec-006 formal governance before implementation;
- historical PR #21 remains research input and is not silently promoted by this landing.
No material current-base correctness, governance, provenance, scope-firewall, or history-safety finding identified.
This is author evidence only. Independent current-base review and all landing checks remain separately required before merge.
AUTHOR_CURRENT_BASE_PASS
IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORITY=NO
MERGE_AUTHORIZATION=NO
TheHalfMoon
left a comment
TheHalfMoon
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
LANDING_CURRENT_BASE_PONYTAIL_PASS
Exact head: 78c7a88c6d809edaa4b8a3a339d367e9bc0cf140 against current base 7302d1b91b1d5b6e2dbbb80893095d36183dc492.
Ponytail / YAGNI disposition: PASS.
The landing surface adds no candidate commit or abstraction. It reuses the already-reviewed two-document research candidate and performs only the minimum necessary current-base qualification after unrelated research-only main movement.
No additional source register, roadmap split, schema, ADR, dependency, implementation scaffold, runtime abstraction, or governance artifact is justified. The existing scope firewall is sufficient and explicitly defers all L0-L10 implementation to future formal governance after Spec 006 closure.
No required scope removal identified.
This is author-side simplicity evidence only and does not replace independent current-base review or current landing checks.
PONYTAIL_PASS
IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORITY=NO
MERGE_AUTHORIZATION=NO
![cubic-dev-ai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/1082092?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
All reported issues were addressed across 2 files
Reply with feedback, questions, or to request a fix.
Re-trigger cubic
|
CUBIC_FINDINGS_RECONCILED_ON_NEW_HEAD The two Cubic P3 findings against historical head Current exact head: Repairs:
Exact delta from the reviewed historical head to the current head is limited to those two files, each with All prior exact-head acceptance/review evidence is treated as historical after this candidate movement. Current-head CI and review are being re-established; no merge authority is claimed by this reconciliation comment. |
TheHalfMoon
left a comment
TheHalfMoon
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
AUTHOR_RESEARCH_FINAL_HEAD_REVIEW_PASS
Exact candidate:
BASE=7302d1b91b1d5b6e2dbbb80893095d36183dc492
HEAD=26b7e19e98ae68e0849f5661b6ffa0dc940d7639
CHANGED_PATHS=2
QUALITY_848=SUCCESS
Author correctness / governance / source-integrity review: PASS.
Rechecked facts:
- current-head diff remains exactly
010-verified-learning-loop-roadmap.mdplus010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md; - the two Cubic P3 findings from historical head
78c7a88...are repaired exactly: the canary invariant is now one underscore-joined token and the source register has a final newline; - compare
78c7a88... -> 26b7e19...contains only one insertion/one deletion in each of those two documents; - prior Hermes and Darwin Gödel Machine provenance corrections remain intact;
- the canonical Herdr research file introduced by PR #85 is untouched and semantically compatible;
- no Constitution, Spec, Plan, Tasks, runtime code, dependency, migration, model/runtime call, authority surface, or landing automation changed;
- L0-L10 remains research sequencing only and explicitly requires post-Spec-006 formal governance;
- PR #21 remains historical research input and is not silently promoted or merged by this candidate.
No material correctness, provenance, governance, history-safety, scope-firewall, or claim-integrity finding identified on this exact head.
This is author evidence only. Fresh independent exact-head review remains mandatory before merge.
AUTHOR_FINAL_HEAD_PASS
IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORITY=NO
MERGE_AUTHORIZATION=NO
TheHalfMoon
left a comment
TheHalfMoon
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
PONYTAIL_RESEARCH_FINAL_HEAD_PASS
Exact head: 26b7e19e98ae68e0849f5661b6ffa0dc940d7639 against canonical base 7302d1b91b1d5b6e2dbbb80893095d36183dc492.
Ponytail / YAGNI disposition: PASS.
The final repair adds no abstraction or feature surface. It makes only two direct review-driven text corrections in the already-required research artifacts. The candidate remains one roadmap plus one primary-source register, with no code, schema, migration, dependency, service, runtime, protocol, or implementation scaffold.
No further split, consolidation, ADR, source database, schema, or automation is justified for this research-only landing. Removing either current artifact would reduce research reproducibility or lose the roadmap itself.
No required scope removal remains on this exact head.
This author-side simplicity review is not independent review and does not authorize implementation or merge.
PONYTAIL_PASS
IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORITY=NO
MERGE_AUTHORIZATION=NO
|
@coderabbitai review Please perform a fresh independent review of exact head All earlier-head reviews are historical. Current-head deterministic Review the final two-document research candidate for material:
Bind the disposition explicitly to |
|
Tip For best results, initiate chat on the files or code changes. 🧩 Analysis chain🏁 Script executed: #!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
repo="TheHalfMoon/Winds"
base="7302d1b91b1d5b6e2dbbb80893095d36183dc492"
head="26b7e19e98ae68e0849f5661b6ffa0dc940d7639"
prior="78c7a88c6d809edaa4b8a3a339d367e9bc0cf140"
echo "== Commit identity and ancestry =="
git show -s --format='base=%H%nbase_subject=%s' "$base"
git show -s --format='head=%H%nhead_parents=%P%nhead_subject=%s' "$head"
printf 'merge_base='; git merge-base "$base" "$head"
printf 'base_ancestor_of_head='
if git merge-base --is-ancestor "$base" "$head"; then echo yes; else echo no; fi
echo "== Exact current-base candidate scope =="
git diff --name-status "$base" "$head"
git diff --stat "$base" "$head"
echo "== Only repair delta from prior reviewed head =="
git diff --name-status "$prior" "$head"
git diff --stat "$prior" "$head"
git diff --no-ext-diff --unified=12 "$prior" "$head"
echo "== Candidate document structure =="
ast-grep outline docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-roadmap.md --items all
ast-grep outline docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md --items all
ast-grep outline docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.md --items all
echo "== Candidate documents and canonical Herdr roadmap =="
for f in \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-roadmap.md \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md
do
echo "--- $f @ head ---"
git show "$head:$f"
done
echo "--- docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.md @ base ---"
git show "$base:docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.md"
echo "== Final newline validation =="
git show "$head:docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md" \
| tail -c 1 | od -An -t x1
echo "== Synthetic merge =="
merge_tree="$(git merge-tree --write-tree "$base" "$head")"
printf 'merge_tree=%s\n' "$merge_tree"
git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r "$base" "$merge_tree"
for f in \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-roadmap.md \
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md \
docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.md
do
printf '%s=' "$f"
git rev-parse "$merge_tree:$f"
done
echo "== PR state, exact-head checks, reviews, and review comments =="
gh pr view 87 --repo "$repo" --json \
number,state,isDraft,baseRefName,baseRefOid,headRefName,headRefOid,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,files,statusCheckRollup,reviews \
--jq '{
number,state,isDraft,baseRefName,baseRefOid,headRefName,headRefOid,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,
files:[.files[]|{path,additions,deletions}],
checks:[.statusCheckRollup[]|{name:(.name // .context),status,conclusion,workflowName}],
reviews:[.reviews[]|{author:.author.login,state,commit:.commit.oid,body}]
}'
gh api "repos/$repo/commits/$head/check-runs?per_page=100" \
-H 'Accept: application/vnd.github+json' \
--jq '.check_runs[]|{name,status,conclusion,app:.app.slug,started_at,completed_at}'
gh api "repos/$repo/pulls/87/comments?per_page=100" --paginate \
--jq '.[]|{id,user:.user.login,path,line,side,body,in_reply_to_id}'Length of output: 67940 🏁 Script executed: #!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail
repo="TheHalfMoon/Winds"
base="7302d1b91b1d5b6e2dbbb80893095d36183dc492"
head="26b7e19e98ae68e0849f5661b6ffa0dc940d7639"
echo "== Final-newline byte =="
last="$(git show "$head:docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md" | tail -c 1 || true)"
if [ "$last" = "$(printf '\n')" ]; then
echo "final_newline=yes"
else
printf 'final_newline=no last_byte_hex='
git show "$head:docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.md" \
| tail -c 1 | xxd -p
fi
echo "== Synthetic merge attempt =="
set +e
merge_output="$(git merge-tree --write-tree "$base" "$head" 2>&1)"
merge_status=$?
set -e
printf 'merge_tree_exit=%s\n%s\n' "$merge_status" "$merge_output"
if [ "$merge_status" -eq 0 ]; then
merge_tree="${merge_output%%$'\n'*}"
echo "== Merge result versus canonical base =="
git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r "$base" "$merge_tree"
echo "== Herdr file in merge result =="
if git cat-file -e "$merge_tree:docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.md" 2>/dev/null; then
echo "herdr_file_preserved=yes"
else
echo "herdr_file_preserved=no"
fi
fi
echo "== Live PR state =="
gh pr view 87 --repo "$repo" --json \
state,isDraft,baseRefName,baseRefOid,headRefName,headRefOid,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,files,statusCheckRollup,reviews \
--jq '{
state,isDraft,baseRefName,baseRefOid,headRefName,headRefOid,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,
files:[.files[]|{path,additions,deletions}],
checks:[.statusCheckRollup[]|{name:(.name // .context),status,conclusion,workflowName}],
reviews:[.reviews[]|{author:.author.login,state,commit:.commit.oid}]
}'
echo "== Exact-head checks =="
gh api "repos/$repo/commits/$head/check-runs?per_page=100" \
-H 'Accept: application/vnd.github+json' \
--jq '.check_runs[]|{name,status,conclusion,app:.app.slug}'
echo "== Review comments =="
gh api "repos/$repo/pulls/87/comments?per_page=100" --paginate \
--jq '.[]|{id,user:.user.login,path,line,side,body,in_reply_to_id}'Length of output: 8179 🤖 web_search executed:
Length of output: 14499
I found no material content, provenance, governance, YAGNI, history-safety, or merge-safety finding. The synthetic merge with canonical
The merge result preserves The earlier direct-diff deletion of the Herdr document resulted from the candidate branch having an older merge base. The synthetic merge is clean and does not delete that document. The two Cubic P3 findings are fully reconciled:
The Hermes provenance correction remains intact. The source register identifies the official The DGM provenance correction remains intact. The source register identifies the original The research references and stated high-level patterns are consistent with the verified public source identifiers. The documents also require future source, license, applicability, evaluator, threat-model, and repository-authority revalidation before formal work. The scope firewall is clear and consistent with the Herdr roadmap. The documents do not amend the Constitution, Spec 006, T079, T080, plans, or tasks. They do not authorize L0–L10 implementation, runtime or model calls, migrations, dependencies, learning code, learned routing, fine-tuning, RL, world models, self-modifying trusted-core behavior, or automatic landing. The roadmap limits the work to research guidance. It preserves the required Both exact-head Therefore, this is a conditional PASS for the reviewed research content at You are interacting with an AI system. |
1 participant
Purpose
Land the research-only Verified Learning Loop roadmap and primary-source register on the current canonical base after completing current-base review reconciliation. This PR does not authorize implementation.
Exact candidate and current base
Changed research files:
docs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-roadmap.mddocs/research/010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.mdReview history and current-head repair
Historical exact-head qualification exists for prior heads, but candidate movement invalidates it as final landing evidence.
On landing head
78c7a88c6d809edaa4b8a3a339d367e9bc0cf140against currentmain, CodeRabbit independently found no material provenance/governance/YAGNI/history-safety/merge-safety issue but returned a conditional landing pass while checks were still running.Cubic then completed review and identified two valid P3 consistency findings:
CANARY_FAILURE_MUST_NOT_BE_NORMALIZED_AS SUCCESScontained a stray space and was inconsistent with the underscore-joined invariant vocabulary.010-verified-learning-loop-source-register.mdlacked a final newline.Both are repaired in the current exact head
26b7e19e98ae68e0849f5661b6ffa0dc940d7639.Exact delta from
78c7a88...to the current head is only:No other research claim, provenance binding, scope firewall, or authority text changed.
Provenance repairs preserved
The source register retains the previously reviewed corrections for:
NousResearch/hermes-agentprovenance without pretending mutable hosted docs are content-bound to the observed repository SHA;jennyzzt/dgm, not a fork;Canonical-base reconciliation
Canonical
mainadvanced from06e515471cf91a0f1d5b257d6e9820096d9a0197to7302d1b91b1d5b6e2dbbb80893095d36183dc492only through guarded research-only PR #85, which added:docs/research/011-herdr-parity-and-beyond-roadmap.mdCurrent-base review established no material interaction or conflict between the Herdr roadmap and this Verified Learning roadmap. Both remain explicitly post-Spec-006 research guidance only.
Scope firewall
This PR is research-only and non-authorizing.
It does NOT:
Any future learning implementation remains gated behind canonical closure of Spec 006 and the normal
Constitution -> Spec -> Plan -> Tasks -> Implementprocess.Historical PR #21 boundary
PR #21 remains historical research input and must not be merged unchanged as the future plan. Post-Spec-006 formalization must reconcile that archive against then-current canonical repository truth and this roadmap.
Current-head landing requirements
The current exact head
26b7e19e98ae68e0849f5661b6ffa0dc940d7639must independently satisfy:qualitysuccess;No force-push, rebase, destructive history rewrite, stale-review reuse, or review bypass is authorized.